| Ep | Date | Special Guest | Panel | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 168 | January 4 | Arthur Treacher | Steve Allen, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 169 | January 11 | Cyril Ritchard | Bill, Jayne, Arnold Stang, Faye | Don McNeill hosts |
| 170 | January 18 | Salute to Ben Franklin | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Professor Leonard Labaree |
| 171 | January 25 | Ernest Borgnine | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Charles Atlas |
| 172 | February 1 | Joe E Brown | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 173 | February 8 | Desi Arnaz | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Lucille Ball | Witness to Lincoln Assassination |
| 174 | February 15 | Dennis O'Keefe | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Audrey Meadows | |
| 175 | February 22 | Gregory Ratoff | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Ann Cullen | |
| 176 | February 29 | Basil Rathbone | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Toni Giilman | |
| 177 | March 7 | Farley Granger | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 178 | March 14 | Brian Donlevy | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | First Girl Scout |
| 179 | March 21 | Phil Silvers Show Cast | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Allan Melvin, Herbie Faye, Billy Sands, Maurice Gosfield, more |
| 180 | March 28 | Easter Show | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 181 | April 4 | William Bendix | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 182 | April 11 | Judith Anderson | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 183 | April 18 | Emmett Kelly | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 184 | April 25 | Marisa Pavan | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 185 | May 2 | Hedda Hopper | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Betty Furness | |
| 186 | May 9 | Jackie Cooper | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Betty Furness | First Fuller Brush Man |
| 187 | May 16 | Armed Forces Special | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Jimmy Durante |
| 188 | May 23 | Cesar Romero | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Don McNeill hosts |
| 189 | May 30 | Great Athletes | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Jack Dempsey, Gertrude Ederle, Cookie Lavagetto |
| 190 | June 6 | Marguerite Piazza | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Broadway producer Michael Myerberg |
| 191 | June 13 | Zippy the Chimp | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 192 | June 20 | Fourth Anniversary | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Many staff members appear on camera. |
| 193 | June 27 | Janet Blair | Bill, Jayne, Arnold Stang, Faye | |
| 194 | July 4 | Agnes Moorehead | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 195 | July 11 | Rocky Graziano | Bill, Jayne, Laraine Day, Faye | Actress Pier Angeli |
| 196 | July 18 | Celebrity Relatives | Bill, Jayne, Mason Morfit, Faye | Steve Allen. Dr Morfit is Garry's brother. |
| 197 | July 25 | Sheree North | Bill, Edie Adams, Ernie Kovacs, Faye | Don McNeill hosts. "Driftin' Johnny" Miller |
| 198 | August 1 | Jack E Leonard | Bill, Betty Furness, Henry, Faye | Don McNeill hosts |
| 199 | August 8 | David Wayne | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Don McNeill hosts |
| X | August 15 | NO SHOW | Democratic National Convention coverage | |
| X | August 22 | NO SHOW | Republican National Convention coverage | |
| 200 | August 29 | Dorothy Lamour | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Don McNeill hosts |
| 201 | September 5 | Ann Sheridan | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 202 | September 12 | Judy Canova | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| X | September 19 | NO SHOW | Eisenhower Presidential Address | |
| 203 | September 26 | James Mason | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Marian McKnight | McKnight is Miss America 1957. Strongman Jack Walsh |
| 204 | October 3 | Paul Newman | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Ann Sheridan | |
| 205 | October 10 | Orson Welles | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Circus attraction Dolly Dimples |
| 206 | October 17 | Burl Ives | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 207 | October 24 | Don Ameche | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Astronomer Clyde Tombaugh |
| 208 | October 31 | Halloween Special | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Bud Collyer |
| 209 | November 7 | No Guest | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 210 | November 14 | Robert Young | Bill, Mary Healy, Henry, Faye | Pianist Joseph Alfidi |
| 211 | November 21 | Douglas Fairbanks Jr | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Mary Healy | |
| 212 | November 28 | Marilyn Maxwell | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Patricia Cutts | |
| 213 | December 5 | Art Linkletter | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Polly Bergen | |
| 214 | December 12 | Good Old Bill | Bill, Henry | No games, and no female panelists. Just the boys. |
| 215 | December 19 | Vincent Price | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Patricia Cutts | Showman Vic Perry, Olympian Tom Courtney |
| 216 | December 26 | Faye Emerson | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Denise Lor |
This site was created with the Nicepage