A YELLOW square indicates an episode which is not publicly available, but which is known to exist.
A RED square indicates an episode that we do not know to exist.
| Ep | Date | Special Guest | Panel | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 65 | January 6 | George Jessel | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Joan Bennett | |
| 66 | January 13 | Arlene Dahl | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Joan Bennett | |
| 67 | January 20 | Dane Clark | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Joan Bennett | |
| 68 | January 27 | Don Ameche | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Bill's wife Carol Ames |
| 69 | February 3 | Merle Oberon | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Polly Bergen | |
| 70 | February 10 | Stu Erwin | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Polly Bergen | Heliodore Cyr's first appearance |
| 71 | February 17 | Art Carney | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Polly Bergen | |
| 72 | February 24 | Phil Silvers | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Polly Bergen | Chef James Beard |
| 73 | March 3 | Ralph Bellamy | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Polly Bergen | |
| 74 | March 10 | Jack Carson | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Polly Bergen | |
| 75 | March 17 | Rocky Graziano | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Polly Bergen | Milton DeLugg |
| 76 | March 24 | Bob Cummings | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Polly Bergen | |
| 77 | March 31 | Jean Hersholt | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Polly Bergen | Steve Allen hosts. |
| 78 | April 7 | Billie Burke | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 79 | April 14 | Thomas Mitchell | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Polly Bergen | |
| 80 | April 21 | Chico Marx | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Polly Bergen | |
| 81 | April 28 | Circus Special | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Polly Bergen | Emmett Kelly, Felix Adler, Gloria Bale |
| 82 | May 5 | Jeanne Crain | Jack Paar, Jayne, Henry, Polly Bergen | |
| 83 | May 12 | Frankie Laine | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Laraine Day, Vaughn Monroe | Bill, Jayne and Henry rotate hosting duties |
| 84 | May 19 | Wally Cox | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Laraine Day | Pat Benoit |
| 85 | May 26 | Leo Durocher | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Laraine Day | Spelling Bee champ William Cashore |
| 86 | June 2 | Audrey Meadows | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Laraine Day | |
| 87 | June 9 | Janet Leigh | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 88 | June 16 | Arthur Treacher | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Laraine Day | |
| 89 | June 23 | Gertrude Berg | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Laraine Day | |
| 90 | June 30 | Peter Lawford | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Laraine Day | |
| 91 | July 7 | Alan Mowbray | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Laraine Day | |
| 92 | July 14 | Morgan the Dog | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 93 | July 21 | Roaring 20s Special | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Laraine Day | Helen Kane |
| 94 | July 28 | Steve Allen | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Laraine Day | |
| 95 | August 4 | Jack Dempsey | Maxie Rosenbloom, Jayne, Henry, Laraine Day | Dennis O'Keefe hosts. |
| 96 | August 11 | Chester Morris | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Laraine Day | Dennis O'Keefe hosts. Table tennis champ Dick Miles |
| 97 | August 18 | Robert Q Lewis | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Laraine Day | Dennis O'Keefe hosts. |
| 98 | August 25 | Charles Coburn | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Dennis O'Keefe hosts. |
| 99 | September 1 | Gregory Ratoff | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Dennis O'Keefe hosts. |
| 100 | September 8 | Tribute to Garry | Bill, Faye, Henry, Laraine Day | Zippy the Chimp, Dennis O'Keefe, many others |
| 101 | September 15 | Edward Arnold | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Laraine Day | |
| 102 | September 22 | Baseball Special | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Laraine Day | Baseball's Sal Maglie, Leo Durocher, Hoyt Wilhelm |
| 103 | September 29 | Joan Bennett | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Laraine Day | |
| 104 | October 6 | Buster Keaton | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 105 | October 13 | Boris Karloff | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Olympic greats including Jesse Owens, Dick Button |
| 106 | October 20 | Sam Levenson | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 107 | October 27 | Louis Jourdan | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 108 | November 3 | Don McNeill | Bill, Audrey Meadows, Henry, Faye | |
| 109 | November 10 | Mischa Elman | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Otto Preminger, Mitch Miller, Morey Amsterdam |
| 110 | November 17 | Jack E Leonard | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Mrs Wyler | Mrs Wyler is selected from the studio audience |
| 111 | November 24 | Thanksgiving Show | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 112 | December 1 | Charles Winninger | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | Scotland Yard detective Robert Fabian |
| 113 | December 8 | Adolphe Menjou | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 114 | December 15 | Carl Reiner | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 115 | December 22 | Christmas Show | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye | |
| 116 | December 29 | Peter Lorre | Bill, Jayne, Henry, Faye |