22     November 27, 1952
Bill, Jayne, Henry, Kitty Carlisle

[Sam Tarratoni] of Brooklyn:  “I’m going to be drafted tomorrow”   

[Charlotte Wartman] from Stamford, CT: “I saw Bill Cullen’s wedding” 
In a simpler era, Bill’s bride casually mentioned on the radio the name of the church where she and Bill would be getting married, and Mrs. Wartman essentially crashed the wedding.  This was his 1949 wedding to Carol Ames, a vocalist appearing at the time on the Arthur Godfrey Show.  They would divorce in 1955 and Bill would marry Ann Macomber on Christmas Eve of that year.   

Special Guest Lizabeth Scott: “I have dimpled knees” 
Beautiful, sultry-voice Scott was a popular leading lady in film noir thrillers of the 1940s and early 50s, but like so many young starlets, her film career fizzled after a few years.  Barely 30 at the time of this appearance, she would only make a handful of movies after it.  Scott was also a stage actress, and rumored to be the inspiration for Eve Harrington, the manipulative understudy in the classic film All About Eve.  Late in her life, she was seen socially with, of all people, Michael Jackson.   

Jane Eisenhauer of Kenosha, Wisconsin: “I voted for Adlai Stevenson” 
It is established that Jane is not related to the president-elect, though nothing is said about their names not even being spelled the same.  This was the sort of safe, silly, middle-of-the-road approach to political humor that drove the show throughout its long, long run.  Why the local newspaper thought Ed Sullivan was the guest, why it didn't mention Garry Moore by name, and why Bill is referred to as "William" is a mystery lost to the ages.

PREVIOUS NEXT